Issue link: https://digital.copcomm.com/i/1225755
64 DGA QUARTERLY Umbrellas of Cherbourg, Damien Chazelle said he and choreographer Mandy Moore had some wait-and-see luxury with dance— they didn't want to just impose routines on newbie musical stars Ryan Gosling and Emma Stone. "We were going to see what their bodies naturally do and create the dances out of those movements," says Cha- zelle. "You start with the nondance version of a scene, and then you grow the dance out of their characters' body language. It's char- acter-focused choreography. The idea isn't without precedent. Gene Kelly did his ver- sion of that. But here you're doing it with un- trained dancers, where you know it's going to be grounded, sort of imperfect, and that was the Jacques Demy thing, to preserve the rough edges." The Past Looms Over the Present O M ET I M E S, T H E F U N is in di- rect shout-outs to the past mas- ters. Chazelle included an umbrel- la shop on the studio lot as a Demy tip of the hat in La La Land. Shankman de- liberately opened Hairspray with a shot de- scending from the clouds into Baltimore as an homage to how Robert Wise began both West Side Story and The Sound of Music. And in the fi rst number, he had Tracy perched on a garbage truck à la Streisand on the tugboat in Funny Girl. "I was very open about the fact that I was going to lay giant Easter egg- y winks at what had come before me," says Shankman. Condon had his own legendary musical director on his mind when making Beauty and the Beast: Vincente Minnelli, the man be- hind beloved classics Meet Me in St. Louis, An American in Paris, The Band Wagon and Gigi. "He was able to get everything you'd want out of a musical," says Condon of Minnelli, "the heightened sense of emotion and conflict that can only be expressed through music and dance. He brings that to composition, to cam- era movement; it's all integrated with him in a way that I don't think has been matched." For the essential moment when Belle and the Beast enter into the centerpiece waltz sequence, Condon's process of devising and revising shots as the choreographer worked with Emma Watson and Dan Stevens, then pinpointing the story beats and emotions, and blocking camera moves with pre-viz due to all the CGI involved, was all about remembering why he responds so deeply to Minnelli's musicals. "It's that crucial Min- nelli element," Condon elaborates, "which is the camera working completely in tan- dem with the dancer, and the camera being an equal participant in making movement come to life." Barbra Streisand approached Yentl's mu- sical scenes with the theater mindset from which she hailed—preserving the moment as a fully performed segment. "The mu- sic doesn't stop, so why should the shot?" she says. "I want things to flow. I want the camera to dance with the actors because in a way they're partners. So then the chal- lenge becomes, 'How can I do this scene in as few shots as possible?' Unless, by the way, it calls for the camera to cut and cut, or be still while the actors move. You want to vary the rhythm in a film. It's like staccato ver- sus legato in music, quick cuts versus long sweeping camera movements. And the most important consideration for me always is, 'How can I use the camera to serve the ac- tor's performance, rather than the other way around?'" When imagining the fl ow of La La Land, Chazelle wanted to honor the way musicals used to be made while taking advantage of what technology could o› er him today—"a little bit of old meets new," he says. It's what led to the opening number on the freeway ramp, and the leads' magic-hour duet on the hillside being envisioned as one-shot daz- zlers, albeit with the tools of the modern di- rector: the Steadicam and, in the case of the CONTINUED FROM PAGE 27 traœ c scene, VFX stitching that made three shots look like a single. "The long take was the aesthetic of the traditional musical, the bread and butter of how Fred Astaire and Gene Kelly musi- cals were done," says Chazelle, referring to the head-to-toe framing that respected the hoofer's total body performing a routine. "Why would you cut? It defeats the purpose of dance. Then when Bob Fosse came along, it was editing to music, and so that approach to musicals became the modern go-to— shoot with 16 cameras and then just cut it in the editing room. But when we made La La Land, thanks to people like Alfonso Cuarón, the one-take had been reintroduced into the grammar of Hollywood filmmaking as an exciting thing to do. So the irony is, by actu- ally returning to the roots of the musical and shooting it pretty traditionally, you were also making it feel weirdly modern." Chu, whose directing credits are dance- packed (two Step Up movies, the rival- dancers web series The LXD), is always infl uenced in his camera choices by what a dancer is doing. "You have to understand the e› ect being given in order to help deliver that, or enhance it, or contrast it," says Chu. "If I'm working with a b-boy who's doing a fl ip, I can just show that, which is equally impressive because you see the human body doing it, or I can counter him on a dolly low to the ground, and bring more energy to that move. It's not just a fl ip, or pointing a toe, or a straight leg. It's 'What are they saying? What do we want the audience to feel?' Then you custom-build it that way." That emphasis on feeling, on characters expressing who they are intensifi ed through song and dance, is what makes directors like Chu excited about the renewed thirst for musicals. But there's also a newness in the air about the genre today, whether it's in the types of music and choreography featured, what the technology allows, the themes ex- plored, or whose story is being told. A musi- cal like In the Heights—a melting pot enter- tainment forged in the energy of its immi- grants' dreams—turns out to be as grounded and truthful as any other kind of movie, says Chu. "Musicals are usually seen as fantasies," he says. "And yes, this one has big spectacles for numbers. But the timing could not have been better for a musical to show a com- munity of joy, love, support and sacrifi ce—a story of America when the story of America is being questioned." ® "He was able to get everything you'd want out of a musical in a way I don't think has been matched." —BILL CONDON On Vincente Minnelli S

